Police on Tybee Island, Georgia, arrested 26 people and seized five firearms, including one weapon they say had been converted into a makeshift machine gun capable of fully automatic fire, during the annual Orange Crush beach weekend that ran from Friday, April 17, through Sunday, April 19.
The island’s 911 center fielded 297 calls for service over the same three days. Officers handed out 100 traffic citations. And all of it unfolded despite what local officials described as a heavy, multi-agency law enforcement operation designed to keep the peace at an event that has tested this small Georgia barrier island for decades.
The numbers tell a familiar story for Tybee Island residents who have watched Orange Crush grow from a college spring-break tradition into a recurring public-safety headache. This year’s 26 arrests mark four more than last year’s total of 22, Fox News Digital reported. In 2024, the event produced 54 arrests. In 2023, the year the festival returned to Tybee Island after a stint in Jacksonville, Florida, there were 26.
Organizers promoted the 2026 event online as expecting more than 50,000 people. The actual attendance figure remains unclear.
Tybee Island officials did not leave security to chance. Beginning Thursday, the day before the festival weekend, residents and visitors saw an increased law enforcement presence from a roster of local and state agencies that included the Georgia State Patrol, the Department of Natural Resources, the Motor Carrier Division, the Liberty County Sheriff’s Office, the Chatham County Sheriff’s Office, and the Chatham County Police Department, all working alongside the Tybee Island Police Department.
Authorities launched a road safety checkpoint on Highway 80, carved out emergency lanes on main roads, and closed the 14th and 16th Street parking lots in an effort to maintain order. Department of Natural Resources officers rode through the crowd on ATVs.
Of the 26 arrests, Tybee Island police accounted for 19. The Georgia State Patrol made seven. State troopers issued 51 of the 100 traffic citations; island officers wrote the remaining 49.
The seizure of five firearms, one of them described by police as a weapon converted to fire fully automatically, stands out in a jurisdiction that is, by any measure, a small beach community. The specific charges tied to the arrests, the identities of those taken into custody, and the circumstances surrounding each firearms seizure have not been disclosed.
When law enforcement has to confiscate a homemade machine gun at a beach party, it is worth asking whether the “safety protocols” in place are solving the problem or simply containing it. The broader national conversation around holding those who threaten law enforcement accountable applies just as much on a Georgia barrier island as it does anywhere else.
Tybee Island Mayor Brian West told Fox News Digital the city’s approach this year closely mirrored what it has done since implementing a safety protocol three years ago, after what he called “a really bad situation” in 2023.
“We had a really bad situation in 2023. And what happened was we had a lot of people that came to this event that weren’t college students. They were older people that were trying to take advantage of the group, and they were bringing drugs and guns.”
West said the security measures have helped filter out the worst actors, leaving a crowd he characterized as more of a “spring break type group than it is a destructive type group.”
The mayor also argued that organized entertainment helps channel the crowd’s energy. Without structured activities, he said, attendees “kinda had to make their own fun. And sometimes that fun really wasn’t the best thing to be doing.”
“So when there’s an activity, when there is a band, when there are things to keep their attention, it works much better.”
That theory was put to the test well before the main weekend. On April 4, police said an unpermitted pop-up event near the Tybee Island Pier and Pavilion drew hundreds of teens. Officers reported hearing a single gunshot around 6:30 p.m., sending the crowd running. Whether anyone was injured in that incident has not been disclosed.
A gunshot two weeks before the main event is not exactly a confidence-builder for residents already on edge. Communities across the country are grappling with rising public-safety concerns, and Tybee Island’s experience shows the challenge does not stop at big-city borders.
Steven Smalls, who runs the rebranded event under the name Orange Crush Reloaded, cast the festival as a positive force for college students nearing graduation. He told Fox News Digital the event is “a college-based thing” and expressed hope that future profits could fund student debt relief or a scholarship at Savannah State University.
“If I wasn’t doing this, then they would just be popping out here. There wouldn’t be no sound, no entertainment. It wouldn’t nothing for them to do, it’d just be them being so pushed out. So me bringing the entertainment and me being here, they come out here to have fun. The police presence, that helps you be safe.”
Smalls praised the working relationship between his organization and city officials, calling the rebrand “probably the best thing that happened.”
His argument carries a certain logic: if the crowd is going to show up regardless, better to have a permitted event with a stage and security than an uncontrolled gathering. But logic and results are two different things. Twenty-six arrests, five seized guns, a makeshift machine gun, and nearly 300 calls for service over a single weekend suggest the “rebrand” has not yet delivered the safe, scholarship-funding celebration Smalls envisions.
Orange Crush dates back decades. Fox News Digital noted it earned a reputation in the early 1990s as a rowdy, crime-filled weekend. The festival left Tybee Island and moved to Jacksonville in 2021 before returning in 2023. Each return has brought a fresh round of promises about improved safety, and a fresh set of arrest statistics.
The year-over-year numbers tell the story plainly. In 2023: 26 arrests. In 2024: 54 arrests. Last year: 22. This year: 26 again, plus a converted automatic weapon. The trendline is not a straight line down. It bounces, and the firearms keep showing up.
Tybee Island Police Capt. Emory Randolph, who provided the preliminary arrest and citation figures, addressed residents’ concerns directly.
“Rest assured that we have heard you and that public safety will always be our top priority.”
That assurance lands differently when the evidence includes a homemade machine gun confiscated at a beach party. Residents of a small island community did not sign up to live inside a law enforcement staging area one weekend every spring. The fact that it takes seven agencies, a highway checkpoint, emergency lanes, parking lot closures, and nearly 300 emergency calls just to get through a three-day music festival raises an obvious question officials have yet to answer convincingly.
When organized criminal behavior, from smuggling rings in South Texas to converted automatic weapons on a Georgia beach, keeps surfacing despite heavy enforcement, the problem is not a lack of police presence. It is a failure of deterrence.
Several questions remain open. What specific charges were filed against the 26 people arrested? What type of firearm was converted to fully automatic fire, and who possessed it? Were any of those arrested repeat offenders from prior Orange Crush weekends? Did anyone suffer injuries during the April 4 gunshot incident? And what was the actual attendance, as opposed to the promotional claim of 50,000-plus?
None of these details have been publicly released. Until they are, Tybee Island officials are asking residents to trust the process while the process keeps producing the same results.
Cooperation between event organizers and local government is fine in theory. But when the annual price of that cooperation is measured in dozens of arrests, seized firearms, and a converted machine gun, the people who actually live on Tybee Island deserve more than reassurance. They deserve a serious reckoning with whether this event belongs on their island at all.
By signing up, you agree to receive our newsletters and promotional content and accept our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.